Why can't you integrate $sqrt(1+(cosx/-sinx)^2$ ?

Question

4044 views around the world

You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License

Answer 1 · 2015-01-29T09:49:56

The answer is: $ln|tan(x/2)|+c$

First of all it's useful to "change" a little the function:

$y=sqrt(1+(cosx/-sinx)^2)=sqrt(1+(cos^2x)/(sin^2x))=sqrt((sin^2x+cos^2x)/(sin^2x))=sqrt(1/(sin^2x))=1/sinx$ .

I used the first fondamental relation of trigonometry: $sin^2x+cos^2x=1$

So we have to integrate: $int1/sinxdx$ .

Before integrate this function, it is useful to remember the parametric formula of sinus, that says:

$sinx=(2t)/(1+t^2)$ , where $t=tan(x/2)$ .

Now the integral will be done with the method of substitution:

$tan(x/2)=trArrx/2=arctantrArrx=2arctantrArrdx=2(1/(1+t^2))dt$ .

Our integral becoms:

$int1/sinxdx=int1/((2t)/(1+t^2))2(1/(1+t^2))dt=int(1+t^2)/(2t)2(1/(1+t^2))dt=int1/tdt=ln|t|+c=ln|tan(x/2)|+c$

Why can't you integrate sqrt(1+(cosx/-sinx)^2sqrt(1+(cosx/-sinx)^2?