Why is aldehyde hydrogen not acidic?

1 Answer
Truong-Son N.
Jul 28, 2016

Because it would make the molecule far too unstable. It probably does have its own #"pKa"#, but it must be exceedingly high because we don't expect it to happen.

If we took acetaldehyde as an example:

The #"pKa"# of the methyl protons (also called #alpha# protons) is #17#. Let's see why those would be more acidic.

If you attempt to deprotonate acetaldehyde, clearly the second option is better.

  • It doesn't exceed an octet for oxygen.
  • The electrons are able to reasonably delocalize. The electronegativity of oxygen is greater than that of carbon, so oxygen is capably negatively charged.
  • The equilibrium on the first one is skewed far to the left, whereas that on the second one is skewed enough to the right.

In fact, it is these #alpha# protons that get deprotonated from ketones, aldehydes, and similar compounds.

Related questions
See all questions in Quick Introduction of Structures
Impact of this question
14789 views around the world
You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License