What are the values and types of the critical points, if any, of f(x,y) = x(2-x-y)f(x,y)=x(2xy)?

1 Answer
Dec 22, 2017

Saddle point at (0,2)(0,2)

Explanation:

I will assume by "critical points" you are referring to the values of xx and yy where the function is stationary.

First we need to find the partial derivatives of the function:

The xx partial derivative:

(partialf)/(partialx) = (2-x-y)+x(-1) = 2-x-y-x fx=(2xy)+x(1)=2xyx
=2-2x-y=22xy

by use of the chain rule.

The yy partial derivative:

(partialf)/(partialy)=x(-1)=-xfy=x(1)=x

We now take both of these equations, and set them equal to 0 to obtain a pair of simultaneous equations which can then be solved to obtain one or more pairs of co-ordinates where our stationary point lies, so:

2-2x-y=022xy=0
-x=0x=0

Immediately we can obviously see x=0x=0 from the bottom equation. That leaves us with:

2-y=02y=0

for the top equation. This has the solution:

y=2y=2

So we have only one stationary point at (0,2)(0,2). Here f(0,2)=0f(0,2)=0

In order to classify the point we now need to find the higher order derivatives, those will be:

(partial^2f)/(partialx^2)=-22fx2=2
(partial^2f)/(partialy^2)=02fy2=0
(partial^2f)/(partialxpartialy)=-12fxy=1

We can classify the points by:

(partial^2f)/(partialx^2)(partial^2f)/(partialy^2)-((partial^2f)/(partialxpartialy))^2 < 02fx22fy2(2fxy)2<0 at (x,y)(x,y)

then it will be a saddle point, or else if:

(partial^2f)/(partialx^2)(partial^2f)/(partialy^2)-((partial^2f)/(partialxpartialy))^2 >02fx22fy2(2fxy)2>0 as (x,y)(x,y)

then it will be a maximum or minimum. Substituting the values of our derivative in we get:

(2)(0)-(-1)^2=-1<0(2)(0)(1)2=1<0 So it is a saddle point. Hence our critical point is a saddle point at (0,2)(0,2).

I have included a contour plot of the function below (I did try a 3d plot at first but the shallowness of the gradient did not make the turning point clear enough). On the image the darker regions represent values of low f(x,y)f(x,y) and the brighter regions represent high f(x,y)f(x,y) in accordance with the plot legend.

We see that going from the bottom left to the top right you go up "over a hill" reaching a maximum at the calculated stationary point. Similarly going from the top left to the bottom right you go through the "bottom of a valley" with the minimum being at the calculated stationary point.

In other words, we notice that the contours from all directions converge at (0,2)(0,2), hence the stationary point of the function. Hopefully this helps to see the idea more clearly.

Mathematica Generated ImageMathematica Generated Image