Question #1628a

2 Answers
Jul 30, 2017

The B-I bond is weaker than the B-Br bond.

Explanation:

Because the bond between B and I is weaker, that means BI3 is easier to dissociate than BBr3. Because it is easier to dissociate, BI3 is a stronger acid.

Oct 7, 2017

BI3 has a longer B—X σ bond.

Explanation:

The boron halides are Lewis acids. Their acid strength depends on their ability to accept a pair of electrons from a Lewis base.

iverson.cm.utexas.edu

Thus, we might expect BF3, with its highly electronegative F atoms, to be the strongest acid of the boron halides.

However, it is the weakest Lewis acid of the group.

It used to be thought that the reason involved overlap between the vacant 2p orbital of B and the filled p orbital of the halogen (π bonding).

Recent research suggests that σ bonding, not π bonding, is the important factor.

In BF3, the B—F bond distance is short.

The sp2 orbitals of B and the 2p orbitals of F are about the same size.

Thus, there is good sp2-2p overlap (σ bonding) between the B and F atoms.

This increases the electron density on the B atom and decreases its Lewis acidity.

In BI3, the B—I bond length is longer and the I atom is using a much larger 5p orbital to form the σ bond.

Thus, the sp2-5p orbital overlap is quite small.

Since the σ electrons around B are much further away, the electron density is greatly reduced.

BI3 is therefore the strongest Lewis acid.

The order of acidity is

BI3>BBr3>BCl3>BF3