What are the products of the following reaction in methoxide in methanol?

enter image source here

1 Answer
May 23, 2016

You aren't given the reaction conditions, so you might have to assume room temperature. But for the sake of learning, we'll assume any temperature.


One issue that might arise is that the solvent is protic, so a strong nucleophile, which tends to also be a strong base (in this case it is), would likely act as a lewis base to donate a pair of electrons and acquire a proton. That would deactivate the nucleophile and disfavor SN2.

However, since the solvent is the protic form of the nucleophile, it doesn't matter whether the nucleophile is protonated or not:

CH3OHCH3CO+H+

because some solvent methanol would have to be deprotonated in order to protonate methoxide, so either way you have your nucleophile.

Thus, the type of reaction depends solely on the substrate cyclohaloalkane.

The substrate is very sterically hindered (the alkyl halide carbon is tertiary), so at room temperature, SN1 is likely.

Or, at elevated temperatures, E1 is likely, because higher temperatures favor elimination over substitution.

A good rule of thumb is that if SN1 is favored, then boosting the temperature favors E1, and similarly, if SN2 is favored, then boosting the temperature favors E2.


Now that we've established that you get either SN1, E1, or both, let's draw both mechanisms.

In the SN1 mechanism, we have to wait until the bromine leaves on its own, because the nucleophile is not strong enough to simply brute-force the reaction and displace the bromide---the steric hindrance is too much.

So, the first step is rate-limiting, i.e. it is slow.

Then, the carbocation intermediate forms, and the methoxide can either:

  • Act as a nucleophile and attack the carbocation center to form a new CO bond, thus forming the SN1 product. This step is fast.
  • Act as a base and steal a proton from the carbon adjacent to the carbocation and form a π bond, thus forming the E1 product. This step is fast.

Thus, we see that the two possible products formed are the original compound with a methoxide displacing a bromide, or the alkene of the original compound.