Why is sn2 concerted?

1 Answer
May 30, 2016

Because the intermediate is short-lived.


A concerted reaction, like an ideal SN2, is simply one that happens in essentially one step.

SN2 MECHANISM

The typical SN2 mechanism is a backside-attack of the electrophilic carbon, inverting the stereochemistry at that carbon.

![http://www.masterorganicchemistry.com/](useruploads.socratic.org)

  • For this mechanism example, the NC: simply approaches carbon-2 from behind, and the three groups on carbon-2 "flip" backwards.

  • Then, NC: attaches by donating a pair of electrons to carbon-2's antibonding orbital, and Br leaves after retracting its bonding pair of electrons.

(The planar transition state illustrates a halfway-point between the initial and final stereochemistry.)

STRENGTH OF NUCLEOPHILE VS STRENGTH OF C-LG BOND

For an ideal SN2 reaction, the CLG bond is strong enough that it doesn't break on its own before the nucleophile attacks, and it's up to the nucleophile to "brute-force" the reaction.

If the nucleophile isn't that strong:

A nucleophile that isn't strong enough leaves an opportunity for the CLG bond to break before the nucleophile has a chance to backside-attack.

This forms a carbocation intermediate through the active participation of only the substrate initially, as in an SN1 reaction mechanism. (The nucleophile attacks later.)

If the nucleophile is fairly strong:

A strong-enough nucleophile allows for the mechanism to involve the participation of both molecules (hence SN2).

In this situation, essentially no carbocation intermediate forms (if it does, it is short-lived).

Hence, the ideal SN2 mechanism is concerted.