What is d/dx(cosx(dy)/dz) where z=sinx?

2 Answers
Aug 9, 2017

I think this is correct.

Explanation:

I assume that the problem is not with the product rule, but a question of how to express d/dx(dy/dz).

Here is one way to approach the question:
The chain rule tells us that

d/dx(g(z)) = d/dz(g(z)) * dz/dx

In this question, g(z) = dy/dz so

d/dz(g(z)) = (d^2y)/dz^2

d/dx(dy/dz) = d/dz(dy/dz) * dz/dx

= (d^2y)/dz^2 * cosx

If our goal is to have only derivative with respect to x

Use the chain rule:

dy/dx = dy/dz * dz/dx = dy/dz *cosx

So dy/dz = secx dy/dx

and

d/dx(cosxdy/dz) = d/dx(cosx(secxdy/dx)) = (d^2y)/dx^2

Aug 9, 2017

y(x) = Ae^(-sqrt(2)sinx) + Be^(sqrt(2)sinx) + sin^2x

Explanation:

Full Question:
Use z=sinx to transform:

cosx(d^2y)/(dx^2)+sinxdy/dx-2ycos^3x=2cos^5x ..... [A]

into:

(d^2y)/(dz^2)-2y=2(1-z^2) ..... [B]

Solution:

The aim is to eliminate x from the DE [A] using the suggested substitution, so as instructed:

Let z=sinx => dz/dx = cosx

By the chain rule:

dy/(dx) = dy/dz * dz/dx

" " = cosx dy/dz ..... [C]

Differentiating again (using the product rule)

(d^2y)/(dx^2) = d/dx cosx dy/dz
" " = (cosx)( (d/dx (dy/dz)) + (d/dx (cos x) )(dy/dz)
" " = cosx( (dz/dx d/dz (dy/dz)) + (-sinx)(dy/dz)
" " = cosx (cosx (d^2y)/(dz^2) ) -sinxdy/dz
" " = cos^2x (d^2y)/(dz^2) -zdy/dz

Now we substitute [C] and [D] into [A], and use z=sinx

cosx(cos^2x (d^2y)/(dz^2) -zdy/dz)+z(cosx dy/dz)-2ycos^3x=2cos^5x

:. cos^3x (d^2y)/(dz^2) -2ycos^3x=2cos^5x

We can cancel a factor of cos^3x

:. (d^2y)/(dz^2) -2y=2cos^2x

And using the identity cos^2 A + sin^A -= 1 we have:

cos^2x = 1-sin^2x = 1-z^2

And so:

(d^2y)/(dz^2) -2y=2(1-z^2) \ \ \ , which is equation [B] QED

Solving the Modified DE

And, now we must solve the DE

(d^2y)/(dz^2) -2y=2(1-z^2)

This is a second order linear non-Homogeneous Differentiation Equation with constant coefficients. The standard approach is to find a solution, y_c of the homogeneous equation by looking at the Auxiliary Equation, which is the quadratic equation with the coefficients of the derivatives, and then finding an independent particular solution, y_p of the non-homogeneous equation.

Complementary Function

The homogeneous equation associated with [B] is

y''-2y = 0

And it's associated Auxiliary equation is:

m^2-2 = 0

Which has two real and distinct solution m=+-sqrt(2)

Thus the solution of the homogeneous equation is:

y_c = Ae^(-sqrt(2)z) + Be^(+sqrt(2)z)
\ \ \ = Ae^(-sqrt(2)z) + Be^(sqrt(2)z)

Particular Solution

In order to find a particular solution of the non-homogeneous equation we would look for a quadratic form, ie a solution of the form:

y = az^2+bz+c

Where the constants a,b,c are to be determined by direct substitution and comparison:

Differentiating wrt x we get:

y' = 2az+b

Differentiating again wrt x we get:

y'' = 2a

Substituting into the DE [B] we get:
(2a) -2(az^2+bz+c) = 2 - 2z^2

Equating coefficients of x^0 and x we get:

z^0: 2a-2c=2
z^1: -2b=0
z^2: -2a=-2

Solving simultaneously, we have:

a = 1
b = 0
c = 0

And so we form the Particular solution:

y_p = z^2

Which then leads to the GS of [B}

y(z) = y_c + y_p
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ = Ae^(-sqrt(2)z) + Be^(sqrt(2)z) + z^2

Wrapping It Up

Now that we have a solution to the DE [B]

y(z) = Ae^(-sqrt(2)z) + Be^(sqrt(2)z) + z^2

We can restore the earlier substitution z=sinx to get:

y(x) = Ae^(-sqrt(2)sinx) + Be^(sqrt(2)sinx) + sin^2x

Which is the General Solution