The Product of the reaction of bromine with E-stilbene is optically inactive yet it has stereogenic centers. Why?

1 Answer
anor277
Dec 10, 2015

Because when a trans -olefin is brominated, the bromines are added from opposite sides; a meso (#RS#) form results.

Explanation:

When an olefin is brominated, the bromine atoms are presumed to add from opposite faces of the olefin (the first #Br# atom adds as an electrophile, and the second bromine atom from the opposite side as a #Br^-# ion (the positively charged bromonium ion intermediate necessitates this approach of #Br^-#). Given the original trans geometry, this addition from opposite faces results in an #RS# compound, a meso isomer, which are not optically active. Why not? Because meso compounds still have a mirror plane of symmetry.

On the other hand, when the cis olefin is brominated, this attack from opposite faces leads to #R*R# or #S*S# isomers, which are non-superposable mirror images, i.e. enantiomers.

You should do the bromination with simple models in order to satisfy yourself that this explanation accounts for the observed stereochemistry.

Related questions
See all questions in Cis and Trans
Impact of this question
4263 views around the world
You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License