MgO Lab: How would your calculated value for the percent composition of magnesium oxide been affected if all the magnesium in the crucible had not reacted?

Calculation:
%Mg=mMgmMgO x 100%

Will the %Mg be over-reported? Under-reported?

1 Answer
anor277 · mrpauller.weebly.com
Jul 30, 2017

Would it not be under-reported?

Explanation:

Look at your quotient.......

%Metal=Mass of magnesiumMass of magnesium oxide×100%......

Incomplete reaction DETRACTS from the denominator, and reduces the measured mass of magnesium oxide...., i.e. we measure mass of magnesium oxide + mass of unreacted metal. Since the starting mass of metal is UNCHANGED, the quotient should reduce...and %yield should be under-reported.....

Since magnesium oxidizes fairly fiercely, this circumstance is unlikely to occur.....of course, given the reaction some mass loss of the magnesium oxide ash could occur.

Here is a short video which summarizes this experiment.

Related questions
See all questions in Percent Composition
Impact of this question
7151 views around the world
You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License