How do you determine if you have an electrophile or a nucleophile?

1 Answer
May 31, 2016

It's not always a black/white "it's definitely this or that", but...

PROPERTIES OF TYPICAL NUCLEOPHILE

  • Should be relatively sterically unhindered for nucleophilic behavior.

Example:

  • If negatively-charged, consider the possibility of either basic behavior or nucleophilic behavior.

Example:

  • If it has a lone pair of electrons, consider the possibility of either basic behavior or nucleophilic behavior. If so, then it should definitely be in an aprotic solvent.

Example:

  • stackrel(..)("N")"H"_3
  • "R"stackrel(..)("N")"H"_2
  • etc.
  • Should be in an aprotic solvent, especially if the nucleophile is negatively-charged or has a lone pair (could undesirably steal a proton and deactivate itself):

Example:

AND has a conjugate acid "pKa" higher than the "pKa" of the solvent (remember the equilibrium lies on the side of the weaker acid, so the higher conjugate acid "pKa" means the equilibrium would favor protonating the nucleophile and deactivating it):

Example:

PROPERTIES OF TYPICAL ELECTROPHILE

  • If positively-charged, generally it makes a nice electrophile.

Example:

  • If a particular atom would possess a partial positive formal charge in a fairly polar bond:

Examples:

  • "HCl"
  • "HBr"
  • "HI"
  • etc.

or if the molecule is polarizable so that the electron distribution can be disturbed towards the more electronegative atom (away from the nucleophile):

Examples:

  • "HCl"
  • "HBr"
  • "HI"
  • "Br"_2
  • "I"_2
  • etc.

then it is probably an electrophile.