If the uncertainty in the position is equal to the wavelength of an electron, how certain can we be about the velocity? Determine an expression for v_x//Deltav_x.

1 Answer
Nov 28, 2016

Well, referring to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, there is one formulation of it that is fairly easy to use in calculations:

bb(DeltaxDeltap_x >= ℏ),

or

bb(DeltaxDeltap_x >= h/(2pi)),

where ℏ = h/(2pi) is the reduced Planck's constant, and h = 6.626xx10^(-34) "J"cdot"s". You may also see ℏ/2, or h/(4pi), but that's beside the point. The point is, it's on the order of .

The de Broglie wavelength is:

lambda = h/(mv)

If the uncertainty in the position becomes numerically equal to lambda, then we can plug in lambda = h/(mv_x) = Deltax to get:

cancel(h)/(mv_x)Deltap_x >= cancel(h)/(2pi)

Since p = mv, Deltap = mDeltav for a particle experiencing little relativistic effects on its mass:

1/(cancel(m)v_x)cancel(m)Deltav_x >= 1/(2pi)

(Deltav_x)/v_x >= 1/(2pi)

Flipping both sides, we get:

color(blue)(v_x/(Deltav_x) <= 2pi)

Since lambda is very small (on the order of nm for electrons), we expect that the uncertainty in the velocity is very large so that the inequality DeltaxDeltap_x >= h/(2pi) is maintained.

That should make sense because if Deltav_x is very large, only then would v_x/(Deltav_x) <= 2pi hold true, since v_x for an electron is generally quite large as well.

EXAMPLE

For instance, the 1s electron in hydrogen atom travels at around 1/137 times the speed of light, or v_x = 2.998xx10^8 xx 1/137 = 2.188xx10^6 "m/s". That means:

(2.188xx10^6)/(Deltav_x) <= 2pi

color(red)(Deltav_x >= 3.483 xx 10^5) color(red)("m/s")

i.e. the uncertainty in the velocity of a 1s electron is AT LEAST ~~15.92% of the velocity of the electron (not at most... at least) when you are sure of the position of the electron to within "nm" of horizontal distance.

It physically means that if we were to try to predict its velocity, we are extremely unsure of which way it's going and at what actual velocity.


In real life, if this were to be the case, then if you shined a laser through a slit of a few "nm" of width, you would see a bunch of constructive and destructive interference on the far walls, indicating the high uncertainty in the velocity along the x axis:

Of course, the de Broglie relation is for electrons, as photons have no mass, but both behave as waves, and so, the slit experiment applies to both.