Why do tertiary alkyl halides react in an "S"_N1SN1 mechanism more easily than "S"_N2SN2?

1 Answer
Aug 4, 2016

Because they are bulky (kinetically stable), and hence block against "S"_N2SN2 backside-attack, giving the alternative mechanism of "S"_N1SN1 a greater percentage of success than "S"_N2SN2.

They also form the most thermodynamically stable carbocation.


"S"_N1SN1 is first-order nucleophilic substitution, so nucleophile strength is an important factor to consider.

Nucleophilicity is a kinetic phenomenon, so a good nucleophile is fast.

  • For "S"_N1SN1 reactions of alkyl halides, the stackrel("central carbon")overbrace("C")-stackrel("leaving group")overbrace"LG" bond is weak, blocked, and the nucleophile is slow. So the "LG" leaves first in an "S"_N1 fashion, giving a first-order process.

Also, because tertiary carbocations are among the most thermodynamically stable, this departure is favorable (not nonspontaneous).

![http://chem.libretexts.org](useruploads.socratic.org)

  • For "S"_N2 reactions of alkyl halides, the stackrel("central carbon")overbrace("C")-stackrel("leaving group")overbrace"LG" bond is weak, open, and the nucleophile is fast. So the nucleophile influences the "LG"'s leaving.

As less substituted carbocations are less thermodynamically stable, the leaving group cannot easily depart on its own, so the joint process makes it a second-order process.

![iverson.cm.utexas.edu)

A bulky alkyl halide like a 3^@ alkyl halide blocks the nucleophile from attacking the central carbon, decreasing the percentage of successful "S"_N2 and increasing the percentage of success in the alternative choice, "S"_N1.

Basically, the site to be attacked is heavily cluttered, which is hard to get past, and the significant thermodynamic stability of the carbocation promotes its formation during the "S"_N1 process.