I don't get my mistake on how to solve #2int (1)/(x^2-x+1)dx#, can you help me?

I got this integral:
enter image source here

Now at the step 2 we take out #3/4#, invert it in #4/3# and multiply with #2#.

But why we don't do the same thing at the step 4?
So:
#8/3int1/(1/3(2x-1)^2+1)dx#
#3*8/3int1/((2x-1)^2+1)dx#
#8int1/((2x-1)^2+1)dx#
and so on?

2 Answers
George C.
Jan 15, 2018

Because the denominator would be #(2x-1)^2+3# and not #(2x-1)^2+1#

Explanation:

In order to use #int 1/(t^2+1) dt = tan^(-1)t+C# we need the denominator to be of the form #t^2+1#.

Attempting to eliminate the factor #1/3# from #1/3(2x-1)^2+1# by multiplying by #3# would result in #(2x-1)^2+3#, which is not what we want.

So instead, we use #1/3(2x-1)^2 = ((2x-1)/sqrt(3))^2#

Andrew I.
Jan 15, 2018

There is a small arithmetic error here:

#8/3int1/(1/3(2x-1)^2+1)dxcolor(red)ne3*8/3int1/((2x-1)^2+1)dx#

The correct working would be:

#8/3int1/(1/3(2x-1)^2+1)dx=3*8/3int1/((2x-1)^2color(red)(+3))dx#

A similar error is also made in going from step 3 to step 4.

So to answer you question, to factor that #1/3# from the bottom would require multiplying that #1# by 3, meaning that the direct integration would no longer work.

- A small recommendation:

There is a standard integral that:

#int1/(u^2+a^2)du=1/aarctan(u/a)+C#

Given the substitution:
#u=x-1/2#
you could use this to evaluate the integral from directly from step 1.

Related questions
Impact of this question
1843 views around the world
You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License